I travel all throughout the state of CT for my job and have explored many italian restaurants in the state. By far, Mama Teresa's restaurant is a favorite of mine. It has a great casual, family atmosphere and they have excellent food. The penne ala vodka, eggplant parmigiana and chicken dishes are some of my favorites. They also have excellent pizza- the crust is perfect and the pizza is cooked through, unlike most places. Great place to bring your family!
Franco's has probably the best NY style pizza in Milford; but they don't know how to treat the customer. Just make sure you know how much your pizza will cost before you have them make it; you may be in for an unpleasant surprise. It cost me over $3 to have pepperoni put on HALF my pizza. I have not been back since.
This is the second time I'm ordering pizza from 4 Brothers. It's a thin pizza and well done. The crust is absolutely great tasting, dark & crispy. I would recommend this to anyone wanting good pizza. First choice is Mama Teresa, second is 4 Brothers. Sorry Bella Napoli you are third-way too oily!